Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Sarah Zahn

June 15, 2025
7:00pm
Magic & Wonder Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

“Beautiful Detours” is a heartfelt journey through the unexpected twists that shape us through our lives. With humor, honesty, and a rich musical palette, I’ll share some of the ways my life hasn’t always gone according to plan…and why that might be the best part. Through songs that span genres and stories told straight from the heart, we’ll explore the unexpected moments that shape us — the surprises, stumbles, and serendipities that make the journey worth singing about!

Act I
“I Will Run” - Atlantis 
”A Way Back to Then” - Title of Show
”Maybe it’s Me”
”Statues and Stories” - The Light in the Piazza (feat. Brianna Wilhelm)
”Se Florindo é Fedele”
”Christmas Lullaby” - Songs for a New World
”New Words” - In the Beginning
”Goodnight Moon”

Act II
”To Build a Home” - The Bridges of Madison County
”Fable” - The Light in the Piazza
”I See Stars” - Mean Girls the Musical
”The Story Goes On” - Baby
”Taking Chances”                    
”Orpheus”

Special Guests
Briella Ashton, Susanna Fuddy, Carly Geiter, Lily Grosh, Anna Hollinger, Sierra Ishler, Alexa Landon, Bonnie O’Connor, Mia Santos, Josie Sirinides, Abby Sollenberger, Rachel Wallace, Anika Walsh

MEET Sarah

Sarah Zahn is a versatile singer and actor known for captivating audiences with heartfelt storytelling and dynamic vocal performances. She loves being part of the Servant Stage family, with which she has been performing since 2016. Favorite Servant Stage roles include Alice Beane in Titanic: The Broadway Musical, Mother in Ragtime, Sister Margaretta in The Sound of Music, and most recently, Mother Foster in Tuck Everlasting. Sarah also loves curating and producing concerts celebrating music for sopranos, most notably Maury Yeston’s acclaimed “December Songs”, produced by The Trust Performing Arts Center in Lancaster. She holds a BA in Vocal Performance and Theatre from the University of Iowa, and has continued her education at NYU Steinhardt. Outside of performing, Sarah owns and operates a lively private music studio, The Vocal Studio of Sarah Zahn, where she helps build her students’ vocal technique, confidence, and love for singing. Learn more about Sarah at www.SarahZahn.com. IG and FB: @SarahZahnOfficial.
"So much love to AZ and KZ, the lights of my life!"

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

THE SINGERS OF SWING!

July 20 2025
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

Join us for a delightful evening with some of the cast of SWING as they share their favorite stories and songs. This is not the touring production of SWING, but a special showcase featuring a charming mix of musical numbers and anecdotes from the talented cast.

Meet our artists

Tirzah Byers, MacKenzie Duvall, Tori Guhl, Kayla Klase, Will Lentz, Brad Leer, Charis Milan, Alli McClune, Jonah McDonald, Ethan Reimel, Jacqui Schaeffer, Max Stiner, Lee Twombly, and Emily Wick

Marshall Lentz - Accompanist • Prescott Kelsey - Audio Engineer

Set List

Coming Soon

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Tyler Hoover

“Growing Up”

August 17, 2025
7:00pm
Magic & Wonder Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

MEET TYLER

For the past two decades, Tyler has been blessed to serve as a performer, director, writer, and composer/arranger with a number of local theatre companies including Servant Stage, Piercing Word, Sight & Sound Theatres, and PRiMA. Tyler’s past Servant Stage credits include Rock Around The Clock, Titanic (Mr. Andrews), and Forever Plaid (Sparky). His in-development musical Prodigal was given its first staged reading at Servant Stage in 2021. Tyler holds both bachelor’s and master’s degrees in Music Theory & Composition from West Chester University and resides in Lititz with his wife, Sandra, and their five children.

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Cassie Meck

‘Returning to Roots’

May 18, 2025
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note from CASSIE

Why do we create? Beauty, eternity, JOY! 

As a new performer in the professional world, sometimes the grind can get overwhelming, and it's easy to be focused on the stress of the fast-paced career instead of why we’re doing it in the first place. I want to use this cabaret as an opportunity to take a step back, and enjoy the beauty of music and story-telling! So, join me for a night of singing those songs that make me remember what I love about making music! 

“He has made everything beautiful in its time. Also, he has set eternity into man’s heart; yet so he cannot find out what God has done from the beginning to the end. I perceived  that there is nothing better for them than to be joyful and do good as long as they live… I perceived that whatever God does endures forever; nothing can be added to it nor anything taken from it. God has done it, so that people fear before him. That which is, already has been; that which is to be; already has been; and God seeks what has been driven away ” Ecc 3:11-15

Set List

“Meadowlark” - Bakers Wife 
“I Don’t Know How To Love Him” - Jesus Christ Superstar
”Somewhere Over The Rainbow” - Wizard Of Oz
”Hopelessly Devoted To You” - Grease
”In My Dreams” - Anastasia
”Life I Never Led” - Sister Act
”Beyond My Wildest Dreams” - The Little Mermaid, with Marian Stephens and Sam Ingram
”I Think I Got You Beat” - Shrek, with Noah Bloom

Intermission

“If This Is Love” - The Notebook
”Only Us” - Dear Evan Hansen, with Charlie Bensinger 
”I Can’t Lose You” - Frozen, with Sam Ingram
”Remembering Home” - Esther, with Sam Ingram and Geoff Morgan
”How Could I Ever Know” - The Secret Garden, with Daniel Gorham
”On The Steps Of The Palace” - Into The Woods
”Nothing Stops Another Day” - Ghost
”I’m Not Afraid of Anything” - Songs For A New World
”Spark Of Creation” - Children of Eden

MEET CASSIE

Cassie Meck is a performer born and raised right here in Lancaster, PA! As a proud graduate of the Sight and Sound Conservatory class of 2024, she has had the amazing privilege to dive right into the professional theater world! Having in the past year performed with theaters such as the American Music Theater, Fulton Theater, and your very own Servant Stage Company, she is so humbled at the opportunities that she has already had and is encouraged and excited for what lies ahead! She is incredibly thankful for this opportunity to share with the community beautiful music and stories. Thank you all for being here tonight! All praise to Jesus Christ, the savior and author of her life!

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

A
March Sisters
Cabaret

April 27, 2025
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

Join us for a delightful evening with some of the cast of LITTLE WOMEN as they share their favorite stories and songs. This is not the touring production of LITTLE WOMEN, but a special showcase featuring a charming mix of musical numbers and anecdotes from the talented cast.

Meet our artists

Tirzah Byers • Sophia Grado • Cat Hughes • Amanda Lewis • Erin Mary Lynch • Abby McCardell • Eliza Moran • Elsa Rogers • Jacqui Schaeffer • Megan Schmidt • Lillyan Steinberg

Katrina King - Accompanist • Prescott Kelsey - Audio Engineer

Set List

"Our Finest Dreams” - Little Women - All
“All The Things You Are” - Very Warm For May - Sophia Grado
“Secret of Happiness” - Daddy Long Legs - Elsa Rogers
“I Just Wanna Be A Star” - Nunsense - Jacqui Schaeffer
“Let Me Be Your Star” - Smash - Abby McCardell and Amanda Lewis
“Think of Me” - The Phantom of The Opera - Megan Schmidt
“Gotta Get Out” - Ordinary Days - Tirzah Byers
“When the Music Played” - Doctor Zhivago - Cat Hughes
“Taylor the Latte Boy” - Amanda Lewis
“How The Other Half Lives” - Thoroughly Modern Millie - Megan Schmidt and Jacqui Schaeffer
“Sweet Liberty” - Jane Eyre - Eliza Moran
“Spark of Creation” - Children of Eden - Erin Mary Lynch
INTERMISSION
“I Know It’s Today” - Shrek - Sophia Grado, Tirzah Byers, Lillyan Steinberg
“Someone Like You” - Jekyll and Hyde - Abby McCardell
“No One Will Bruise” - Atlantis - Erin Mary Lynch
“Secondary Characters” - Title Of Show - Jacqui Schaeffer and Tirzah Byers
“One Perfect Moment” - Bring It On - Lillyan Steinberg
“Flight” - Erin Mary Lynch and Elsa Rogers
“I’m The Greatest Star” - Funny Girl - Sophia Grado
“Journey to the Past” - Anastasia - Amanda Lewis
“In His Eyes” - Jekyll and Hyde - Cat Hughes and Eliza Moran
“I’m Not Afraid of Anything” - Songs for a New World - Megan Schmidt
Poem Reading
“There Can Be Miracles” - Prince of Egypt - All

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Justin & Kelly
Mazzella

present

Comfort and Joy

Pianist: Kendra Bigley
Guest Singers: Jacob Cummings and Karrah Nordlund
Audio: Brian Yawney

December 15, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

Set List

Act 1
Winter Wonderland/Let it Snow! by Felix Bernard, Richard Bernhard Smith, and Jule Styne; arr. Nicola Sgaramella
Christmas Valentine by Ingrid Michaelson, Jason Mraz, and Dave Barnes
The Very Best Day of the Year by Jeff Meegan, David Tobin, and Mark Armstrong
Sleigh Ride by Leroy Anderson
Merry Christmas, Darling by Richard Carpenter and Frank Pooler
The Christmas Waltz by Jule Styne 
Winter Song by Ingrid Michaelson, Sara Bareilles, feat. Karrah Nordlund
The Christmas Song by Mel Torme and Robert Wells; arr. Richard Walters
What Are You Doing New Year’s Eve by Frank Loesser
Baby it’s Cold Outside by Frank Loesser
Love and the Weather from White Christmas by Irving Berlin

Act 2
Hallelujah by John Stephens and Tony Gad 
Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas from Meet Me in St. Louis by Hugh Martin and Ralph Blane 
Believe from Polar Express by Glen Ballard and Alan Silvestri
Next Christmas by Michael Arden; arr. Nicola Sgaramella 
Deliver Us by Andrew Peterson and Jill Phillips
O Holy Night by Placide Cappeau and Adolphe Adam; arr. Ellie Goulding 
Labor of Love by Andrew Peterson and Jill Phillips
Mary Did you Know?  by Mark Lowry and Buddy Greene; arr. The Hound + The Fox  
Carol Fantasia by Benjamin Harlan, Andy Albritton, and Tom Fettke.

Every year, Christmas time always brings people together, encourages everyone to slow down for a few weeks, and to pay closer attention to the things and people around them. The music especially helps bring us into that Christmas spirit! 

Join local performers Justin and Kelly Mazzella for an evening of Christmas tunes, with classics from names like Nat King Cole and The Carpenters, to some modern renditions by John Legend, Kacey Musgraves, and Josh Groban, as well as a holiday singalong meant for you to take part in! Tonight, Justin and Kelly would love to share with you their love for Christmas and the Holiday season, as well as why it’s so special to them. Merry Christmas! 

MEET THE ARTISTS

Justin Mazzella is delighted to be performing with Servant Stage again! Growing up in Charleston, SC, Justin has now been a Lancaster local for over ten years. Justin was a part of some early Servant Stage shows, such as H.M.S Pinafore, Forever Plaid, and Old Time Radio Gospel. He has been a performer at Sight and Sound Theaters for eight of those ten years, found in roles such as Nathanael/Judas in Jesus, Xerxes in Queen Esther, David in David, Moses in Moses, and currently Nebuchadnezzar at select performances in Daniel through 2024. Regional credits include Assassins, Bonnie and Clyde, Our Town, Godspell, Wild Party, The Fantasticks, and more. Justin is thrilled to have become a recent father to his beautiful daughter, Mia, and is excited to join his wife Kelly for an evening of singing some theater and Christmas tunes! 

Kelly J. Mazzella is excited to make an appearance with Servant Stage in their Cabaret Series alongside her husband, Justin. She was born and raised in Mountain Top, Pennsylvania. Credits include Walnut Street Theatre, Margaritaville; Fulton Theatre, Secret Garden in Concert, The Sound of Music, Man of La Mancha, The Play That Goes Wrong; Arizona Broadway Theatre, Spamalot. Kelly holds a BFA in Musical Theatre from The Boston Conservatory. Justin and Kelly welcomed their first child last year and are looking forward to all God has in store for their family. Thanks for having us!

Kendra Bigley has built a career as a chamber musician, teacher, music director, vocal coach, and accompanist at such institutions as Temple University, Lancaster Bible College, Fulton Theatre, and the Trust Performing Arts Center. Her favorite collaborations at the Trust PAC include recitals with violinist Carla Leurs, soprano Amy Owens, and clarinetist Doris Hall-Gulati. Bigley holds a Masters degree in Collaborative Piano/Opera Coaching from Temple University and a Bachelor of Music in Applied Piano from the Eastman School of Music. As a repetiteur and coach for Temple Opera Theater, Bigley assisted with productions of Pelleas and Melisande, Dark Sisters, Hänsel und Gretel, and Le Nozze di Figaro. Her credits as music-director/conductor include Working, Little Shop of Horrors, You’re A Good Man Charlie Brown, I Love You-You’re Perfect-Now Change, Little Women, My Fair Lady, The Music Man, Ruth, Cinderella, and Titanic, the Musical, for which she won the BroadwayWorld Regional Award for Best Musical Director. Bigley lives in Lancaster City with her husband, Dr. Robert Bigley. They have three grown children and two grandsons.

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Broadway’s
Brandon Cameron

Presents ‘Autumn Leaves’

November 17, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

We're welcoming home Servant Stage alum and current HADESTOWN cast member, Brandon Cameron!

A Note from Brandon

Returning from one of my biggest Seasons of Change, join me in sharing some of my evergreen songs. Music has always been an anchor throughout my life. So many different genres, artists, mentors, and friends have woven their way into who I am with music. Come share in a night of appreciation, celebration, and sharing hopes for the future - through a motley collection of the songs that are always in my head: from Crooners to Country, Broadway to Pop, and even some original tunes. I’ll have some friends and family joining me on stage, so don’t forget to bring yours! “..Winter’s coming on the breeze. Gather ‘round before Autumn leaves..”

MEET Brandon

Brandon Cameron, although originally from New Jersey, considers Lancaster, PA his second home. He has performed and worked with multiple theatre companies throughout Pennsylvania - including Servant Stage, American Music Theatre, and Sight & Sound Theatres. Brandon has worked as a performer along the east coast since he was seven years old and began working as an educator, director, and choreographer in high-school. He continued performing and teaching through his college education and graduated with a BFA in Musical Theatre in May of 2022. In September of that year, he joined the Broadway company of Hadestown where he remains currently. While in Hadestown, Brandon still works as an educator; teaching Broadway Masterclasses, Voice, Acting, and Dance to students from all over the country.

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Briana VanVleet

October 6, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note From Briana

Journey with me through my life in song. Growing up, I was surrounded with music and dancing. My siblings and I would watch and dance along to any movie with music for as long as my parents would allow. My parents, both performers at some point in their lives, made sure to play all kinds of music in the home from gospel to classical arias. This music has had a huge influence on my vocal style and my love for performance. I want to share with you the many artist and songs that have had the biggest impact on my life from a little girl at the age of four to now. I will also bring along some family and friends that I love singing with to join me on stage. I look forward to reliving some of my pivotal core memories with all of you!

Program Order

Act 1

Serenity Prayer - India Irie
Reflection - Mulan
In My Own Little Corner - Cinderella
Almost There - The Princess and the Frog
Shadowland - The Lion King
Golden Slumber/ Carry that Weight - Sing
Zero to Hero - Hercules
Just My Imagination (Running Away with Me)
I Know Where I've Been - Hairspray

Act 2

Home - The Wiz 
The Prayer - Donnie McClurkin and Yolanda Adams
Summertime - Porgy and Bess
At All Cost - Wish
When you Believe - Prince of Egypt
Love Will Find a Way - The Lion King 2
Once Upon a Time - Brooklyn the Musical
Take a Little Piece from God - Cece Winans

Meet Briana

Briana VanVleet is a lover of laughter and smiles and looks forward in continuing to put smiles on people's faces in her first cabaret. She grew up in Southern Maryland where she was homeschooled alongside her 2 siblings by their mother who filled the home with music, dancing, and learning. She made her way to Lancaster, PA in 2016 where she attended the Sight and Sound Conservatory. After graduating, she decided to make the Lancaster area home and began to pursue a career in performing. She has had the privilege to perform in many Servant Stage productions starting with the Broadway musical The Civil War (2017) to I’ll Fly Away (2024). Some of her favorite performed productions include Sight and Sound's Samson (Ensemble) , Servant Stage's production of the Broadway musical The Civil War (Ensemble), Servant Stage’s Rock Around the Clock (Featured Performer), Ragtime (Sarah’s Friend), and Magic and Wonder Dinner Theatre’s Jukebox Jive (Greaser). She is so thankful to all of her family and friends who have supported her on this journey. She hopes you enjoy watching the show as much as she will enjoy performing it! 

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Adam & Kristin Zembower

‘One Second and a Million Miles’

September 15, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note From Adam & Kristin

As we approach 2 years of marriage and 5 years together, time has really seemed to have flown by. And what better way to reflect on the winding musical path that led us to each other and our journey as a couple through songs we love! Join us as we sing musical theatre, folk, worship, and pop to give you a glimpse into the good, the bad, the ugly, and the wonderful of our love story that God so carefully orchestrated. From “Donny Novitsky” to “Envy Green” and “One Second and a Million Miles,” we hope to bring you a beautiful, heart-warming, tear-jerking show- from our hearts to yours!

Meet Adam and Kristin

Adam Zembower- Adam has been a musician and singer his whole life, and is ecstatic to be performing this cabaret with his wonderful wife of almost two years! Originally from New Paris, PA, Adam achieved his BS in Worship Arts from Lancaster Bible College. During and after college, he started a career on the stage, with roles including Motel (Fiddler on the Roof, LBC), Henry Higgins (My Fair Lady, Cavod), various roles in Sight and Sound’s Jesus, Miracle of Christmas, Queen Esther, and David. With Servant Stage, you may have seen him as Mr. Hartley in Titanic, and in Rock Around the Clock and I’ll Fly Away. Currently, Adam works as the Director of Worship and Production at Victory Church and as a substitute guitarist at the Fulton Theatre. Enjoy the show! Soli Deo Gloria.

Kristin Zembower- Kristin is definitely the luckiest girl in the world to be married to Adam AND get to perform this cabaret with him! A Lancaster native, Kristin attended Lancaster Bible College for her BFA in Musical Theatre. She has had the privilege of working for many wonderful theatres and the honor of playing dream roles such as Katherine (Newsies, Servant Stage), Rapunzel (Rapunzel, Fulton Theatre), Ensemble (Ragtime Benefit Concert, Fulton Theatre), Ens/Dance Captain (Footloose, Revival), Mermaid (Big Fish, Servant Stage), and Lina Lamont (Singin In the Rain, LBC). Kristin has also served as a dance educator and music director for young performers. Enjoy the show! Soli Deo Gloria.

ACT 1

You’re The Top - Anything Goes

Not for the Life of Me - Thoroughly Modern Millie

Donny Novitski - Bandstand

Flowers - Hadestown

Left Behind - Spring Awakening

Time Stops - Big Fish

First Date/Last Night - Dogfight

Safer - First Date

Only Us - Dear Evan Hansen

ACT 2

Song that Goes Like This - Spamalot

Envy Green - The Arcadian Wild

All Good Gifts - Godspell

No One Else - Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812

Run Away With Me - The Mad Ones

All I Ask of You - Phantom of the Opera

My Baby - Jonathan Reid Gealt

Break Every Chain / Revelation Song

One Second and a Million Miles - Bridges of Madison County

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

A
MARVELOUS
Cabaret

August 18, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

Join us for a delightful evening with the cast of THE MARVELOUS WONDERETTES as they share their favorite stories and songs. This is not the touring production of THE MARVELOUS WONDERETTES, but a special showcase featuring a charming mix of musical numbers and anecdotes from the talented cast.

Meet our artists

Kayllen Cox
Riley Fidler
Samantha Grinage
Tori Guhl
Bethany Huff
Kayla Klase
Lily Klees
Cassie Meck
Ella Murray
Megan Lynn Schmidt

Marshall Lentz - Accompanist
Brian Yawney - Audio Engineer

SONG LIST

ACT ONE
Mama Who Bore Me (Reprise) - Spring Awakening
Live Out Loud - A Little Princess
Nothing Short of Wonderful - Dogfight
Light in the Piazza - Light in the Piazza
Alto's Lament
When He Sees Me - Waitress
In the Bedroom Down the Hall - Dear Evan Hansen
Raining - Rocky
Thank You for the Music - Mamma Mia
Let Me Be Your Star - Smash

ACT TWO
Six - Six
Stupid With Love - Mean Girls
I Couldn't Know Someone Less - Daddy Long Legs
When the World was Mine - The Count of Monte Cristo
Flight
How to Return Home - Tales from the Bad Years
Love Will Come and Find Me Again - Bandstand
A Story Of My Own - The Clockmaker's Daughter
Thank You & Goodnight / Sincerely - The Marvelous Wonderettes

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Britt Jarkowsky, Kayleigh Jarkowsky, Callaghan Petrosky, Nolen Petrosky

June 23, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note

A sibling is more than just someone who shares parents with you. No one has as much of an understanding of your specific experience in life as someone who grew up right alongside you. For many of us they’re our greatest competitor, confidant, partner in crime, and built in best friend. For as many of us with siblings will tell you, no matter how much you might want to get rid of your sibling, you’re stuck with them. So the Jarkowsky Sisters and the Petrosky Brothers invite you to join them for an evening of music, conversation, and comedy that hopefully harkens back to the days where your backyard was an alien planet, the greatest song in the world was a xylophone and kazoo duet, and the scariest thing you had to contend with was hiding the lamp you broke from your mother.

About our singers

Britt Jarkowsky is a local performer, voice teacher, and theatre educator. Britt holds a BFA in Musical Theatre from LBC with a focus on voice. She was most recently seen in FIDDLER ON THE ROOF as Tzeitel with Servant Stage. Some other favorite credits include ‘the regional premiere’ of THE PROM (Alyssa Green) EPAC, THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL (Sandy U/S, Ensemble) Revival Productions, YOU’RE A GOOD MAN CB (Sally), HELLO DOLLY (Minnie Fay) LBC; THREE LITTLE PIGS (Sui) Red Accordion Studios; RAGTIME, TITANIC (Ensemble), BIG FISH (Josephine U/S) Servant Stage. Britt serves on staff at Servant Stage as a project manager and part of the theatre education program, and is also the Director of Junior Company. Besides Servant Stage, some of her favorite production team credits include: EPAC (ASM-Conductor Les Miserables, MD Rudolph Jr, Finding Nemo Jr., Elf Jr.), Lancaster Bible College (ASM Singin’ In The Rain, SM Radium Girls), LAMS, and Chester County School Of The Arts. Britt is not only incredibly thankful and excited to do this cabaret with her sister, but with Nolen and Callaghan who have been like family, onstage and off, since that very first acting class in 2016. This foursome is long overdue.

Kayleigh Jarkowsky is so excited to be a part of this cabaret with her older sister, Britt, and two childhood friends, Nolen and Callaghan! Kayleigh is a rising sophomore at Ohio Northern University studying Musical Theatre and Marketing. Some of Kayleigh’s favorite Servant Stage credits include OLD TIME GOSPEL RADIO HOUR, DON’T ROCK THE JUKEBOX, RAGTIME, FROZEN JR. (Anna) and THE LITTLE MERMAID JR. (Ariel). Other favorites include PIPPIN (Catherine) with Susquehanna Stage, NEWSIES (Katherine) and SEUSSICAL (Gertrude) with HCS, and most recently THE ONU HOLIDAY SPECTACULAR (Youth Performance Supervisor) and 9 TO 5 (Ensemble, Judy U/S) at ONU. You can also catch her this summer in THE MARVELOUS WONDERETTES! Kayleigh is honored to be a part of this cabaret and to be pursuing a career that brings her so much joy. She would like to thank her family, friends, and teachers for always supporting her. Psalms 100:2

Callaghan Petrosky is a rising senior in high school and is excited to perform once again with Servant Stage. He is honored to share the stage with his brother Nolen, and his wonderful friends Britt and Kayleigh! Some of his favorite credits include THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA (Phantom), GODSPELL (Jesus), OUR TOWN (The Stage Manager), and he most recently played Fyedka in Servant Stage's FIDDLER ON THE ROOF. One of his proudest moments was being chosen as the 2022 recipient of the HTAA Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical for his role as Scuttle in THE LITTLE MERMAID. This fall, he will be appearing as Tulsa in Gypsy at EPAC. He is so grateful to his many friends and supporters, but specifically to: The Servant Stage team, the Phamily (I'm calling it that guys), the pineapple crew, his parents, his rad brother Nolen, and God. "The universe is, and we are."

Nolen Petrosky is an actor/musician born and raised right here in Lancaster Pennsylvania. Nolen is a multi-instrumentalist, (proficient in ten musical instruments), singer, actor, writer, and on some occasions a semi-competent dancer. He has appeared in ten Servant Stage Productions, including NEWSIES (Race, u/s Jack Kelly), RAGTIME (Houdini, u/s Younger Brother), BIG FISH (Zacky Price, u/s Will Bloom), and most recently FIDDLER ON THE ROOF (Perchik). A few other favorite credits include the title character in THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY, The LIGHTNING THIEF (Percy Jackson), the North American premiere of IT HAPPENED IN KEY WEST, and Crutchie in NEWSIES which earned him the HTAA for Outstanding Supporting Actor, a distinction which he shares with his younger brother Callaghan.

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Brittany Beitzel

August 18, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note From Brittany

Coming Soon

MEET Brittany

Brittany originally hails from Huntington, WV, but has been a proud Lancastrian for the last 12 years! You may have seen her at Sight & Sound Theatres, in shows such as JONAH, NOAH, MOSES, SAMSON, MIRACLE OF CHRISTMAS, JESUS, and QUEEN ESTHER. She has also performed with Piercing Word, PRiMA Theatre, and has performed and directed many times with Servant Stage Company. This past year she also had the privilege of Directing for Lancaster Academy of the Performing Arts, and considers it such an honor to work with young people in this vibrant theatre community. She holds a degree in Musical Theatre and Psychology from Liberty University, and is currently pursuing her Master’s degree there in Clinical Counseling. “All of my love to my husband Aaron and my wonderful son, Dawson. The two of you are my daily joy and my greatest earthly gifts from God. -This show is dedicated to my Mother, Paula. Thank you for being my best friend in this life, your selfless love, and your lifelong example of how to love others well.”

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Amanda Lewis, Wes Wilson, Richard Weaver & Catherine Weaver

March 17th, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

About our singers

Amanda Lewis is a Virginia raised girl who made Lancaster her home when she moved here to perform and study at Sight & Sound Theatres. Locally you may have seen her in Servant Stage’s The Marvelous Wonderettes (Suzy), EPAC’s Beauty and the Beast (Belle), Cavod’s Little Women (Jo March) and most recently Magic and Wonder’s Jukebox Jive (Female Swing). In March of this year be sure to come see her in Cavod’s production of Anastasia, as well as her Cabaret with Servant Stage! Some other favorite shows include Mary Poppins (Mary Poppins), Hairspray (Amber Von Tussle), Seussical (Gertrude), and ‘Peter Pan’ (Wendy). Along with dance teaching and performing, Amanda is also a wedding hairstylist and most importantly, a wife and a mom. She loves life and every opportunity she’s given! All her love to Noah.

Wes Wilson is thrilled to be back at Servant Stage for his first cabaret performance! He was first seen at Servant Stage in their production of My Fair Lady as part of the quartet. He most recently appeared in Susquehanna Stage's performance of Rent portraying his dream role of Angel. Wes has been blessed to perform on many of the theater stages in the area, including EPAC, Dutch Apple, Popovsky, The Belmont, and Sight and Sound Theatres. His credits include Newsies (Crutchie), Mamma Mia! (Sky), and The Boys In the Band (Donald). Wes is a marriage and family therapist in Lancaster, working at Sun Point Wellness where he caters to marginalized communities. He wishes to dedicate this performance to his 2017 conservatory sidekick and constant friend, Amanda. I can't wait to sing with you again.  

Richard Weaver grew up in Lancaster County and has been performing locally for many theaters including The Bird-in-Hand Stage, Fulton Theatre, Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre, Servant Stage, and many more! Some of his favorite roles include Ensemble in Treasure Island at the Fulton Theatre, Laurie in Little Women and Dimitry In Anastasia at Cavod Theatre. When not performing he can be found teaching acting classes, playing DnD, and directing shows! A big thanks to his wife Catherine, friends, family, teachers, and God.

Catherine Weaver is excited to present this cabaret with her husband and dear friends. She holds a BFA in musical theatre from Samford University and has performed with various companies including Hampstead Stage Company, Birmingham Children’s Theatre, and National Theatre for Children. Catherine works regularly at the Bird-in-Hand Stage, performing most recently in Our Christmas Dinner, The Home Game, and Dear Soldier Boy . She has also performed locally with Magic & Wonder Theater, Piercing Word, and Cavod Theatre. Special thanks to Amanda and Wes for including her in one of their dream projects. Love forever to her wonderful husband Ric. Enjoy the show!

A Note

Broadway Through The Ages: 100 years of Broadway duets and trios!

Join us for a night of walking down memory lane with some of Broadways most beloved shows. Amanda Lewis, Wes Wilson, Ric Weaver and Catherine Weaver will be taking you through 100 years of the best Broadway duets and trios. Songs from Anything Goes, Sound of Music, Into the Woods, Phantom, Suessical, Secret Garden, Wicked, Aladdin, Dogfight, Bonnie and Clyde, Next to Normal, Mary Poppins, Cinderella, Finding Neverland, Shrek, Newsies, Brightstar, Annie, Dear Evan Hansen and much more. You don’t want to miss out on this one night only cabaret filled with so many fun numbers. We hope you’ll join us on our walk through Broadway history!

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Joshua William Green

April 21, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

Meet joshua

Joshua William Green is a multi-talented artist who works as an actor, singer, dancer, choreographer, and director. Originally from Youngstown, Ohio, he moved to Lancaster from Manhattan in 2021 during the pandemic. Joshua is no stranger to Servant Stage Company, having been a part of many productions on and offstage, including his recent portrayal of Coalhouse Walker Jr. in RAGTIME fall 2022. He has also performed at various theatres in the Lancaster area such as The Fulton, PRiMA Theatre, and Sight & Sound Theatres. Joshua made his directorial debut in October 2022, directing THE COLOR PURPLE at Ephrata Performing Arts Center. He also became a mainstage director and choreographer for SSC last fall with BIG FISH. Joshua started studying dance at the age of 7 and became a principal dancer in the Archangel Dance Theatre Company. He studied Musical Theatre and Dance at Youngstown State University and the American Musical and Dramatic Academy in NYC. Some of his favorite credits include FINDING NEVERLAND 2nd NATIONAL TOUR (Mr. Henshaw/Hook U/S), RAGTIME NATIONAL TOUR (Booker T. U/S), ROCKTOPIA ON BROADWAY! (Vocal Captain and BGV), and 2018 GRAMMY AWARDS (BGV for Sam Smith).

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Sierra Naomi

THE HUMAN HEART

May 19, 2024
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note From Sierra

Do me a favor…take a quick moment and think of one of your favorite songs. How do you feel when you listen to it? When you hum it? If you sing, when you sing it? Science has been studying the effects of music on our brains and our bodies for a while and we’re just starting to really understand its full impact. It creates a feeling of connectedness, lowers stress, and helps us regulate our emotions. Researchers have found it even helps people process their feelings. For me personally, music and theatre have been two of the most formative parts of my life. From a very young age, they have helped me navigate my own emotions, provided me with community, and filled me with incredible passion. The value of youth arts education cannot be overstated. This cabaret, titled “The Human Heart” is my love letter to musical theatre and all it gives to us from youth to adulthood. Join me and some wonderful guest artists as we share a few of my favorite songs from across the Broadway canon. I can’t wait to spend a wonderful night with you celebrating the power of music!

MEET SIERRA

Sierra Naomi is an actor, singer, director/producer, and teaching artist who has graced stages and delighted audiences from New York to California. After many years in Chicago and NYC, she is now proud to be part of the wonderful Lancaster community. Sierra's relationship with Servant Stage began almost immediately after arriving in the city with her role in Ragtime in the fall of 2022. Since then she's loved supporting the Servant Stage mission in many ways, most recently as the director for the Winter Youth production of Seussical. Locally, you may have also seen her on stage at The Fulton and Prima. Over the years, Sierra's been fortunate enough to step into the shoes of some incredible characters, including Mrs. Lovett (Sweeney Todd), Narrator (Joseph...Dreamcoat), Fantine (Les Miserables), Witch (Into the Woods), Lucille Frank (Parade), and Queen Sigrid Hallbourne in the new upcoming television series King’s Blade. Off stage, Sierra works to add more light to this industry as a director/producer and teaching artist. One of her favorite projects was as the live director and festival co-producer for the 2020 Allen and Gray Musical Festival, as well as a concert series she produced and hosted called “New Voices,” bolstering the work of new musical theatre writers. Sierra holds a degree in Musical Theatre from Chicago College of Performing Arts as well as a certificate from the Conservatory at The Stella Adler Studio of Acting in NYC. 1 Cor 16:14 @sierranaomi_nyc

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Matthew & Brianna Wilhelm

December 3rd, 2023
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

About Matthew & brianna

Brianna Wilhelm is thankful to work with Servant Stage once again and is excited to bring you the Christmas Cabaret for the 2023 season with her wonderful husband, Matthew. Brianna is a local actress and teacher of the performing arts, having graduated from Lancaster Bible College with a BFA in Musical Theatre (’21). She serves as the Operations Assistant for The Trust Performing Arts Center, Production Coordinator for Lancaster Bible College, and has the privilege to direct the theater program at Donegal High School. Some of Brianna’s favorite credits include U/S Maria (The Sound of Music - Servant Stage), Emma Schmidt (Prodigal - Servant Stage), Kathy Selden (Singin’ in the Rain - LBC), Sandy (Grease - Riverbank Theatre), Kim MacAfee (Bye Bye Birdie - LBC), and Madeleine Astor (Titanic - Servant Stage). Brianna is immensely looking forward to kicking off the Christmas season with you this year!

Matthew Wilhelm is excited to appear in another Servant Stage production! Previous Servant Stage appearances include Bob Cratchit (A Christmas Carol), Olin Britt (The Music Man), 1st Officer Murdoch (Titanic), and John Brooke (Little Women). Other local credits include Mr. Banks (Mary Poppins - LBC) and Noah Claypole (Oliver! - Gretna Theatre). Matthew has been a cast member at Sight & Sound Theatres since 2021 (Queen Esther, David, Moses, & Miracle of Christmas) after graduating from their conservatory program in 2015. He and his amazing wife, Brianna, make their home in Strasburg, PA. Merry Christmas!

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Geoffery Morgan

October 1st, 2023
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

A Note From geoffery

I am so excited to bring this show to you titled “Snapshots”. This piece looks into many different points in time, and memorable experiences as we explore my story through song. Things that have impacted me, shaped the performer and storyteller that I am, and propel the work that I do now. We will touch on genres like Gospel, Musical Theater, Classical, Opera, Pop and more. Come join me and some very talented guests as we travel through my story and hopefully, you will leave with a new snapshot memory of your own story.

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Jacob & Cassandra Cummings

July 2nd, 2023
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Dinner Theater (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

About Jacob & Cassandra

Cassandra Cummings is thrilled to be a part of Servant Stage’s new Cabaret Series! She received a BFA in Musical Theatre from MNSU Mankato, and has since been blessed to be working full time as an actor, until last year. Cassandra is now devoting most of her time as a stay-at-home mom, but loves the opportunities to share in the arts as much as she can! Some of her favorite roles include Sarah (The Civil War), Rusty (Footloose), Dragon (Shrek), and Esther (Samson). She has spent most of her time in Lancaster working at Sight & Sound Theatres and was most recently seen as Woman 1 in Servant Stage’s production of Songs for a New World. Cassandra can be seen again with Servant Stage this fall as the Witch in Big Fish. She is thankful to her incredible husband and family for always supporting her. Galatians 5:22-23

Jacob Daniel Cummings is also thrilled to be a part of Servant Stage’s new Cabaret Series! Jacob works as a full-time cast member at Sight & Sound Theatres. He recently was seen at Sight & Sound in the cast of David, and is currently performing the role of Aaron in Moses. Jacob has been fortunate to have many opportunities to work with Servant Stage in various capacities: performing (Old Time Radio Gospel Hour, The Civil War, Around the World in 80 Days), teaching classes, and, now, joining in the Cabaret Series. All praise to God and many thanks to his gracious, beautiful wife, Cassandra. 

A Note From Jacob & Cassandra

“Ever After”

Join Jacob and Cassandra on a musical journey through their relationship. The ups and downs, the good and the not-so-good… It’s a far from perfect story. But who said “happily ever after” was ever perfect?

The music will range from pop to musical theatre to worship with songs like “She Used to Be Mine,” “La Vie en Rose” & even some highlights from Servant Stage’s past show, The Civil War. Jacob and Cassandra invite you to share an intimate night in telling their story. 

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Ray Hilton

June 4th, 2023
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

About Ray

A native Texan, Ray Hilton loves living and working as an actor and educator in Lancaster County. When not busy parenting four kids between the ages of 4 and 16 alongside his wife, Jaime, Ray works as a performer at Sight & Sound Theatres, where he also teaches performance in Shakespeare at the Conservatory. Some of his favorite roles include Edward Bloom (Big Fish), Officer Barrel (Urinetown), Ira Stone (Laughter on the 23rd Floor), Captain Pierce (The Civil War: Musical), and Benedick (Much Ado About Nothing). He is thrilled for the opportunity to leap into a cabaret with Servant Stage. 

A Note From Ray

Storytelling is a big part of my life and the life of my family. We love sharing our own stories and the stories of others through a creative lens, doing our best to utilize the gifts that God has given us. My “Caba-Ray” *wink* is a night for me to share not only parts of my story but also take a chance to step in into the melodic lines and lyrics of some of the best storytellers out there, from Rodgers & Hammerstein to Jason Robert Brown to Sara Bareilles, including fun twists on familiar tunes. I’m looking forward to sharing some great music with everyone and the stage with some fantastic guests.

Sunday Night Cabaret Series

Kristen Brewer

May 14th, 2023
7:00pm
Magic and Wonder Theatre

Sunday Night Cabaret Series performances are held at Magic and Wonder Theatre (3065 Lincoln State Rte, Paradise, PA 17562). All shows are pay-what-you-will, in keeping with our mission to make exceptional theatre accessible.

For Fun

“For me, this cabaret is about dusting off the songbooks. Diving back into the love I have of musical theatre. Even thinking through the set list has been a cathartic and exciting trip down memory lane! I truly can't wait to share this evening with everyone!

Set list will include classics such as "Memory" and "My Man" as well as contemporary music theatre songs from Waitress, SIX, and so much more in between!”

About Kristen

Kristen Brewer is currently a writer, composer and director at Sight and Sound Theaters. She attended Belmont University for classical vocal performance and started her career as a performer. While she still performs occasionally, she truly enjoys creating content and helping others tell stories from the stage or screen in the best way possible. She is married to the delightful Ben Brewer and they live in Lancaster, PA with their two boys.